• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer

MCMHA

  • Home
  • About
  • Free Term Life Insurance Quotes
  • Insurance Categories
    • Term
    • High Risk
    • Disability
    • Whole
    • Seniors
    • Reviews
    • No Exam
    • Estate Tax
  • Contact

Do I Need Supplemental Disability Insurance?

If you have a standard disability insurance policy through your employer, are you adequately covered? In many cases, the answer to that question is no. That’s because standard disability insurance only replaces a certain percentage of your pre-disability income. If that won’t be enough for you to live on, you may need supplemental disability insurance.

What Is Supplemental Disability Insurance?

Supplemental disability insurance is coverage that exceeds your regular disability insurance policy. That’s important, because regular disability policies have strict benefit limits. It is entirely possible that the amount of the monthly benefit that you receive on a regular disability policy will be inadequate to cover your basic living expenses.

For example, an ordinary disability insurance policy may replace only between 40% and 60% of your regular pay. It may also put a ceiling on the dollar amount that you can receive, limiting it to not more than somewhere between $3,000 and $5,000 per month.

If you earn $10,000 per month, but your regular disability policy caps out at $5,000 per month, you may be forced to draw down your savings or to use credit cards in order to make up the difference between the benefit and your actual cost of living.

The Benefits of Supplemental Disability Insurance

The most obvious advantage to having a supplemental disability insurance policy is that your monthly benefit will be higher, and more closely resemble your pre-disability income level. That will give you a better chance of sustaining your finances through a period of long-term disability, without having to tap your savings or go into debt.

Supplemental disability insurance policies will typically pay as much as 80% of your pre-disability income. But that may not be the most important benefit.

Supplemental disability insurance also as a broader definition of income. For example, while a basic disability policy may recognize only your base salary in computing your monthly benefit, a supplemental policy will also take into account commissions, bonuses, and other forms of incentive income. Since these represent a substantial amount of income for many employees, including them in a benefit calculation will be a critical factor.

Even if you are accustomed to living on substantially less than what you earn, the extra funds that you receive through your supplemental disability insurance policy can be used to help you cover medical expenses. This is important because disability is usually accompanied by various therapies or even surgeries. And even though you have health insurance, there are always co-payments, deductibles, and uncovered expenses, that the extra cash from your supplemental disability insurance policy will help to cover.

Supplemental Disability Insurance is Even More Important if You are a High Income Earner

We touched on this earlier, but it’s well worth repeating since it is important if you are a high income earner. Since regular disability policies will only pay up to a certain point – generally no more than $5,000 per month – they may be inadequate if you are a high income earner.

If you make more than $250,000 per year, or more than $20,000 per month, a disability policy that replaces only $5,000 per month will be insufficient. Adding a supplemental disability insurance policy to your coverage certainly won’t make up 100% of your lost income, but it will get you a lot closer.

Similarly, if a large percentage of your income is from sources other than base salary – like commissions and bonuses – you also need to seriously consider adding a supplemental disability insurance policy to the mix. Again, regular disability policies do not take commissions and bonuses into account in calculating your monthly benefit.

If a regular disability policy replaces 60% of your pre-disability income, and you earn $10,000 per month, $5,000 of which is in commissions or bonuses, your monthly benefit will be limited to $3,000. That’s 60% of the base salary portion of your compensation only. The net result is that you will be forced to live on no more than 30% of your regular income. Should the disability persist for more than a few months, you may have to resort to tapping into your savings or going into debt.

How Supplemental Disability Insurance Policies Work

If you have a regular disability insurance from your employer, they may also offer supplemental coverage. Many employers however do not, so you may have to purchase your own policy. That can be a major advantage in itself, since you will be able to take the policy with you if your current employment ends.

But there may be an even bigger advantage to having your own policy. Since you will be paying the premiums for the supplemental disability insurance policy, the monthly benefits that you will receive upon filing a claim will come to you on a tax-free basis. If the policy is paid by your employer, then the benefits will be fully taxable as ordinary income. A private supplemental disability policy can reduce your monthly benefit, maybe even substantially.

If you take a private supplemental disability insurance policy, your application will have to be underwritten for approval. The insurance company will take into account your age, overall health, occupation, and income. This is similar to the process of approving an application for life insurance. The insurance company will want to know the type of risk you present and the likelihood that you will file a claim. But if you have qualified to purchase life insurance in the past, you’ll probably have little difficulty with a supplemental disability insurance policy.

There are a lot of considerations that go into purchasing supplemental disability coverage. We can help you get the right policy at the best possible price. Fill up the form below and we’ll get back to you.

Category: Disability

About Kevin Mercadante

The following are posts by staff writer, Kevin Mercadante, who is a professional personal finance blogger, and the owner of his own personal finance blog, OutOfYourRut.com. He has backgrounds in both accounting and the mortgage industry.

Previous Post:When Can I Make a Disability Insurance Claim?
Next Post:Why Do You Need Disability Insurance When You Can Apply for Social Security?

Sidebar

red arrow down

GET INSTANT QUOTES

Use the form below to compare rates from the nation's leading insurers


Categories

  • Disability
  • Estate Tax
  • High Risk
  • No Exam
  • Reviews
  • Seniors
  • Term
  • Whole

Quick Navigation

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use – Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy MCMHA.org

Insurance Categories

  • TermTerm life insurance can be a wonderful way to protect your family very inexpensively. This section is full of articles which explain the ins and outs of term life; how much you might need, how to buy it inexpensively and where the best places are to buy the coverage you need. This section also discusses some types of term life you might want to avoid.
  • High RiskIf you have an illness or disease you may think that it will be impossible to buy life insurance. Actually, that is not true. Many insurance companies cater specifically to people like you. Here’s how to get the coverage you need at a price you can afford even if you face health challenges.
  • Disability
  • WholeMany life insurance agents love selling whole and universal life. Of course they make very fat commissions from these products. But are they the best choices for you? In some cases, maybe. But in many cases, whole life is not your best bet. This section explains how whole life works and who it might be best suited for.
  • SeniorsSeniors face unique challenges when it comes to life insurance. The older we are, the more expensive life insurance is. Also, as we age, we encounter more health challenges and those can also make it more difficult for seniors to find affordable life insurance. These posts will help you understand the market for senior life insurance and how to get the right coverage in place at the right price.
  • ReviewsLife insurance is a long term proposition. How do you know the insurance company you are doing business with today will be there when you need them several years from now? Of course there is no way to predict the future and anything could happen. But it’s just plain smart to understand a little about the insurance company you are dealing with before signing a contract. Here are a number of reviews to help you get an insider peak at several insurance companies as of the date of the review. As I said, things change so make sure you re-examine the current financial strength of any insurance company you are dealing rather than rely on past reviews.
  • No ExamBuying life insurance usually involved filling out forms, getting a physical, the insurance company looking through your doctor’s records and you waiting for several weeks for an answer. If you don’t have the time or patience for this, you might consider buying ‘No Exam” life insurance. Here are several posts to help you understand the pros and cons of this decision and how to go about this and save the most money you can.
  • Estate TaxEstate tax is not something most people need to worry about – at least for now. But it’s an important topic to understand none-the-less. That’s because Congress could change the law. If they do that, you might very well find yourself facing a stiff and devastating estate tax problem. Having said that, if you don’t have a taxable estate right now, it’s important to understand that too. Don’t let insurance agents sell you a solution for a problem you don’t really have.

MCMHA.org

Helping you make smart decisions about life insurance for you and your family.

Life insurance is a critical piece in the puzzle for those looking to secure their family’s finances.

Copyright © 2026 · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Assaf Katzir