• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer

MCMHA

  • Home
  • About
  • Free Term Life Insurance Quotes
  • Insurance Categories
    • Term
    • High Risk
    • Disability
    • Whole
    • Seniors
    • Reviews
    • No Exam
    • Estate Tax
  • Contact

Why You Should Avoid Life Insurance Comparison Websites

These days, everybody is buying everything on the web that they can. After all, that’s where the deals are right? Not necessarily, and certainly not when it comes to life insurance. I’ve had some experience trying to buy life insurance on one of those life insurance comparison websites. Believe me, it’s not all that it’s cracked up to be.

The last thing you’ll get is the very thing you came for

In theory, the reason that you would go to a life insurance comparison website is to find the greatest amount of life insurance coverage for the least expensive premium. You’ll go to a comparison site in the hope that you’ll get what you came for – side-by-side comparisons of various life insurance plans offered by different companies.

Is that what happens? Nope.

You can spend hours on a life insurance comparison website and never get what you came for. There are inherent reasons why that’s true, but we’ll get to that in a minute.

You’ll be asked for personal information

Once you go on one of those websites, you’ll quickly discover that you’re not getting any information unless you first supply an incredible amount of personal information. How much you’ll need to supply will depend upon the website. At a minimum, they will ask for basic information such as your name, age, occupation, address, email address, and phone number (the contact information is really, really important).

Some will be even more invasive. They may ask a series of medical questions, as well as questions about your financial situation, including income and assets. The worst offenders will ask you for your Social Security number. You should never give that out except to a trusted source you plan on doing business with.

But some sites will require your Social Security number in order for you to even get into the site. If that’s the case, click the exit button – fast! You never want to give something that important on an unknown site.

No quotes will actually come from the site itself

If you’re like me, you’ll go on such a site in the hope that you’ll actually get quotes. That wasn’t my experience. Life insurance comparison websites apparently don’t exist to give out direct quotes. They want to know everything about you, and just when you think you’ve provide enough information to get a few quotes, they cut you off.

Here’s why…

You’ll be contacted by dozens of insurance agents

Remember all the information we said that life insurance comparison websites collect? That’s the true reason for their existence! It isn’t to give you life insurance quotes. It’s to get information from you that can be shared with the people and businesses that are subscribed to the site.

A life insurance comparison website is simply a centralized information collection system. It is a pure marketing scheme to get thousands of people to provide personal information – especially contact information – that will be sold to various entities who will use the information to get your business.

Within seconds of signing up for one of the sites, you’ll start getting phone calls from dozens of insurance jockeys looking to sell you a policy. The life insurance comparison website is a starting point alright – for the people looking to sell you something.

But it gets worse.

Congratulations – you’re now on 100 mailing lists!

The information that you provide to a life insurance comparison website will be placed in a database. That database will produce mailing lists that the site owners will sell to various insurance entities so that they can solicit you for business. You will become a “lead” on a mailing list that will be sold to any parties who are interested.

As best as I can tell, the websites have a tiered operating method. Insurance agents can pay a certain price to get immediate leads from the website as unsuspecting customers sign-up. That’s why you get a bunch of phone calls before you even leave the website.

A second tier of insurance agents buy the information from mailing lists, presumably at a lower cost per lead than what they would pay for immediate sign-ups. You could be getting calls as a result of being part of that list months after the fact.

Unknowingly, you are voluntarily participating in a lead generating service, not a life insurance comparison website.

The better way to buy life insurance

If you’re seriously interested in getting reliable quotes for a solid life insurance policy, contact a reputable insurance agent, one who represents many different companies. That will give you an opportunity to have one agent who is specifically looking for the best policy for you among many different providers. It’s much more effective than having dozens of agents contact you about programs you’ve never even heard of.

Some products and services are better if they are not purchased on the Internet. Life insurance looks to be one of them.

Category: Term

About Kevin Mercadante

The following are posts by staff writer, Kevin Mercadante, who is a professional personal finance blogger, and the owner of his own personal finance blog, OutOfYourRut.com. He has backgrounds in both accounting and the mortgage industry.

Previous Post:Why Having Multiple Life Insurance Policies Isn’t a Crazy Idea
Next Post:Six Questions You MUST Ask Your Life Insurance Agent

Sidebar

red arrow down

GET INSTANT QUOTES

Use the form below to compare rates from the nation's leading insurers


Categories

  • Disability
  • Estate Tax
  • High Risk
  • No Exam
  • Reviews
  • Seniors
  • Term
  • Whole

Quick Navigation

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use – Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy MCMHA.org

Insurance Categories

  • TermTerm life insurance can be a wonderful way to protect your family very inexpensively. This section is full of articles which explain the ins and outs of term life; how much you might need, how to buy it inexpensively and where the best places are to buy the coverage you need. This section also discusses some types of term life you might want to avoid.
  • High RiskIf you have an illness or disease you may think that it will be impossible to buy life insurance. Actually, that is not true. Many insurance companies cater specifically to people like you. Here’s how to get the coverage you need at a price you can afford even if you face health challenges.
  • Disability
  • WholeMany life insurance agents love selling whole and universal life. Of course they make very fat commissions from these products. But are they the best choices for you? In some cases, maybe. But in many cases, whole life is not your best bet. This section explains how whole life works and who it might be best suited for.
  • SeniorsSeniors face unique challenges when it comes to life insurance. The older we are, the more expensive life insurance is. Also, as we age, we encounter more health challenges and those can also make it more difficult for seniors to find affordable life insurance. These posts will help you understand the market for senior life insurance and how to get the right coverage in place at the right price.
  • ReviewsLife insurance is a long term proposition. How do you know the insurance company you are doing business with today will be there when you need them several years from now? Of course there is no way to predict the future and anything could happen. But it’s just plain smart to understand a little about the insurance company you are dealing with before signing a contract. Here are a number of reviews to help you get an insider peak at several insurance companies as of the date of the review. As I said, things change so make sure you re-examine the current financial strength of any insurance company you are dealing rather than rely on past reviews.
  • No ExamBuying life insurance usually involved filling out forms, getting a physical, the insurance company looking through your doctor’s records and you waiting for several weeks for an answer. If you don’t have the time or patience for this, you might consider buying ‘No Exam” life insurance. Here are several posts to help you understand the pros and cons of this decision and how to go about this and save the most money you can.
  • Estate TaxEstate tax is not something most people need to worry about – at least for now. But it’s an important topic to understand none-the-less. That’s because Congress could change the law. If they do that, you might very well find yourself facing a stiff and devastating estate tax problem. Having said that, if you don’t have a taxable estate right now, it’s important to understand that too. Don’t let insurance agents sell you a solution for a problem you don’t really have.

MCMHA.org

Helping you make smart decisions about life insurance for you and your family.

Life insurance is a critical piece in the puzzle for those looking to secure their family’s finances.

Copyright © 2026 · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Assaf Katzir